A Techblah! Review of the iPad
By JT
The Apple™ phenomenon is running rampant here in Australia. We have iPods – in a multitude of sizes and specs; the Apple Mac collection – including the iMac; the MacBookPro; the MacBookAir etc. And let’s not forget the iPhone.
Apple.com (
www.apple.com/ipad) tout the iPad – which was avail
able for public consumption here in Australia on the 8th May 2010
1 – as a “Magical and revolutionary product at an unbelievable price.”
2 News.com has even given the iPad its own news category.
3
So … given all of this hoopla … and given the fact that I have some opinions on the
iPad … I thought that I would voice aforementioned opinion by doing a review. And here we are.
Introducing the iPad
The Apple™ iPad is a tablet device that has been niche designed for media consumption, personal digital assistant (PDA hereafter) and general web browsing. Media consumption includes music; books; magazines; games; news; movies etc. The PDA functions include the likes of calendar and contact management and emails.
Design
The iPad has Apple’s customary ‘sexy’ trademark look and feel. Being fairly light – weighing roughly 730 grams – it is not as large as a notebook and isn’t encumbered by a physical keyboard.
The 9.7 in (roughly 245 mm) screen is first-rate and the aluminium casing reinforces the feeling that the build quality is excellent.
Just like the iPhone, the ‘Home’ button is located on the bottom edge of the screen. The speakers are also positioned on the bottom edge and a standard head phone jack is positioned on the … so that you can listen to it discreetly at need.
For me personally, the design is only just good enough to hit the mark – like horseshoes and handgrenades. And there are a few reasons for that.
Firstly, the iPad ‘kind of’ looks like an oversized iPhone to me … they have always reminded me of a squashed boat or flattened barge. The iPad just emphasises this.
The iPad is an awkward size. You can’t quite classify it as a handheld device … and yet it is definitely too compact to be a notepad. While this may be exactly what some people are after; for me it just felt inelegant. It is too small to type effectively and it is too large to hold in your hands to use as an eReader or to watch movies on for any more than two (2) hours.
Specifications
- The basic specifications of the iPad are:
- Height: 242.8 mm
- Width: 189.7 mm
- Depth: 13.4 mm
- Weight: 680 grams (WiFi) & 730 grams (WiFi & 3G)
- Display: 245 mm
- Capacity: 16GB; 32GB or 64GB
- Built-in battery – lithium polymer – roughly 10 hrs duration
- Operating system: iPhone OS 3.2 – upgrade to iOS 4 coming.
A couple of things that the iPad doesn’t have is:
- No phone function / capability
- No camera – stills or video
- No USB connectivity
- Speaker components aren’t good
Battery and Accessories
The iPad has a built in lithium polymer battery – which is good for about 10 hours of usage. However, you will need to go to Apple should it need to be replaced.
There are heaps of accessories available which include everything from protective casing to wireless keyboards. See here4 for more details.
User Interface (UI)
As you can see, the iPad’s UI is pretty much the same as the iPhone or the iPod Touch … put simply it is user friendly and very intuitive. The interface is very similar to the iPhone …
Applications are prevalent. You perform functions using the touch screen. The patented rotating display makes for a fantastic user experience.
However, I think that where the iPad really falls down in the user interface is the virtual QWERTY keyboard. For me the virtual keyboard was dreadful.
In portrait mode – it was too small and so it was cumbersome to type (especially if you have large hands / fingers). When in landscape mode the size was better but it was still annoying because as usually rest my fingers on the keys while I type – on the iPad’s keyboard every time I did that I got letters I didn’t want.
The next pain point for me was how the numbers worked on the virtual keyboard. Numbers are displayed by pressing a specific function ‘.?123’ button. The letters disappear and you can then type symbols and numbers. And if you are used to using a key pad for numbers, you will be disappointed as only the QWERTY numbering is available.
The whole virtual keyboard interface works … but to me it just felt cumbersome. Perhaps I could get used to the idiosyncrasies of this keyboard with time and use … but I doubt it.
Applications
There are virtually thousands of applications for the iPad – applications for anything from games to education to productivity. You know what they say, if you can think of it … there’s probably an App for it.
The applications available for the iPad are being continually created and improved ... which will make the way that you use the iPad better.
Most of the applications that I tried (YouTube, Wall Street Journal, etc) worked pretty much the same as they did on the iPhone. However, the iTunes interface was just a bit different than the usual look and feel. This was confusing … but not insurmountable.
Generally, with the exception of the virtual keyboard, the UI and Apps made the iPad like every other Apple product … intuitive and user friendly.
Gaming
Gaming on the iPad is pretty basic. The high-end graphics (3D technology etc) doesn’t seem to be there yet. So, if you’re a hard core gamer the iPad probably won’t impress you. However, if you can get used to the game controls (touch screen and movement – v – keyboard / joystick / mouse) and you don’t expect too much from a gaming perspective … then the iPad will probably fit the bill.
Media
It is with media consumption that the iPad finds its niche.
For music, iTunes and the internal storage provide standard iPod functionality. Please note the difference in UI for iTunes mentioned above.
Movies that you obtain through applications or iTunes; coupled together with the 10 hour battery life make this an excellent device for watching movies. Imagine watching movies for an entire eight (8) hour flight without having to recharge.
The speakers – which have been mentioned before – again let this device down. I recommend using a good set of headphones.
Internet and Web Browsing
Internet and web browsing functionality was pretty good. Social networking, news, financials, search engines etc all worked fine.
However, one major drawback was the lack of flash. This issue has been pretty well discussed to death before today … so I will just mention that the plethora of applications seemed to cater to the ‘Flash Deficit’. For example, YouTube has an app that lets iPad users view YouTube video content. In saying that, there are sites (that utilise Flash) that just won’t work well if you use your iPad to view them.
The Verdict
If you are after a machine that is smaller than a notebook, but larger than a smart phone. Or if you are looking for tool that is media centric, can also function as a PDA and provide good generic web browsing capability. Then the iPad is a great device for you.
Given that this is one of the first of these tablet PCs on the market, I think that it still has a little way to go. As subsequent models emerge I think that the price should come down and the more problematic issues will be addressed.
The iPad as a product designed for a specific market segment, and so with that in mind I am giving it a five (5) out of ten (10) ‘Bazingas’.
Personally however, I don’t have the need nor the inclination to spend $628.00 (up to $1,024 for the 64GB WiFi & 3G model ) for another device that doesn’t have all of the bells and whistles. I think that later models will be better and cheaper.
For my money, I think that the iPhone 4 will do all of the things that I need a mobile device to do – without the limitations of the iPad.
I am giving the iPad a personal score of three (3) out of ten (10) bazingas.